Skip to main content

Table 5 The reporting situation and proportion in Chinese literature

From: Evaluation of traditional Chinese exercise for knee osteoarthritis (KOA): an overview of systematic reviews

Authors, year

Number of fully

conforming entries

(% of rate)

Number of partially

conforming entries

(% of rate)

Number of non-conforming entries

(% of rate)

ZENG Ling-feng 2018 [32]

25(59.52%)

5(11.90%)

12(28.57%)

Li Ruojin 2021 [33]

25(59.52%)

5(11.90%)

12(28.57%)

Li Zimeng 2020 [34]

24(57.14%)

4(9.52%)

13(30.95%)

WANG Li-dong 2022 [35]

25(59.52%)

5(11.90%)

12(28.57%)

LIU Wen-jun 2020 [36]

10(23.81%)

5(11.90%)

27(64.29%)

XIA Lu-qin 2020 [37]

11(26.19%)

3(7.14%)

28(66.67%)

XIE Hui 2016 [38]

26(61.90%)

5(11.90%)

11(26.19%)

XIE Yu 2015 [39]

23(54.76%)

5(11.90%)

14(33.33%)

Mean

21.125

4.625

16.125

Total percentage

50.45%

11.04%

38.51%